Most alias service comparisons start with a price table, and that is exactly why they are useless. The $3-per-month tool and the free tool can behave completely differently the moment a signup form tries to validate your address, and price tells you nothing about that. The axis that actually matters is domain type: does the service hand you an address on a domain you control, or a shared disposable domain that half the internet has already blocklisted? Get that wrong and you will be debugging failed registrations instead of reading your mail.

Disposable domains and real domains behave nothing alike

Shared disposable domains are convenient and free because thousands of people use the same one. That is also the problem. When a service like Mailinator or a throwaway generator hands you something@shareddisposable.com, that domain ends up on the blocklists that fraud-prevention vendors sell to anyone with a signup form. You do not find out at signup. You find out three weeks later when a password reset never arrives because the site silently rejected the address.

A real domain alias works the other way around. You register or own a domain, or the provider gives you one that is not shared with strangers, and every alias is a distinct address on infrastructure that looks like a normal business mailbox. Form validation passes because there is nothing to flag: valid syntax, a resolving MX record, and no reputation baggage. That difference is structural, not cosmetic, and no amount of price comparison surfaces it.

This is why a catch-all domain is described as the only genuinely unlimited option in the guide published by AllMail. A catch-all domain accepts mail for every address on the domain, so you never create aliases one at a time. You type any local part you want at signup and it lands in one mailbox. The trade-off is spam exposure, since dictionary attacks will hit random addresses, but filtering by recipient handles most of it.

How the big providers handle aliases, and where the ceilings are

Gmail is the friendliest starting point because plus addressing delivers mail to the base Gmail address with zero setup. Add +shopping to your address and filter on it later. The catch is that a growing number of signup forms strip the plus tag before storing it, which quietly collapses your per-site tracking into one address. Plus addressing is great for personal filtering and weak as a privacy tool.

Paid products raise the ceiling but not to infinity. Google Workspace allows up to 30 aliases per user, which is plenty for a small team but tight if you need many email addresses for registrations across dozens of websites. Microsoft 365 documents a proxy address limit of roughly 300 addresses per mailbox, and plus addressing is enabled by default in Exchange Online, so Microsoft shops get more headroom but still a finite one. Gmail also allows sending as up to 99 other addresses, and it limits gmail.com address changes to three times, which matters if you were planning to cycle through fresh base addresses.

Why the ceilings rarely matter for the right use case

None of these limits are the real constraint for most people. Thirty aliases is enough for a business mailbox with role addresses like billing@ and support@, and 300 proxy addresses is more than any human will use by hand. The limits bite when you want a unique address for every single service you touch, which is a different job than business mailbox aliases. That job belongs to per-site alias providers or a catch-all, not to the alias slot on your Workspace plan.

The category that passes both filters: per-site aliases on your own domain

SimpleLogin and AnonAddy (now addy.io) sit in a category of their own. They generate a unique alias for each site, but the alias lives on a domain you bring or a provider domain that is not a shared disposable. That combination is the only one that survives both the plus-tag stripper and the disposable blocklist. The form sees a clean address with no + in it, and the domain has no reputation for throwaway signups.

The practical effect is that you get true inbox routing without exposing your primary address. Each alias forwards to your real mailbox, you can disable one when a site starts spamming, and replies can go out from the alias if you configure it. A custom domain mailbox through one of these providers costs a few dollars a month at most, and the domain is yours, so switching providers later does not break every account you signed up with.

Compare that to a catch-all mailbox, which is simpler but noisier. A catch-all has no per-site creation step, which is its charm, but it also accepts mail for typos and dictionary guesses. Per-site aliases cost you one extra click at signup and give you a cleaner inbox and cleaner revocation. If you sign up for a lot of services, the extra click pays for itself.

A practical way to choose without getting distracted by price

Start by asking what you are protecting. If you just want to sort incoming mail, plus addressing on Gmail costs nothing and works today, as long as you accept that some forms will strip the tag. If you run a business and need role addresses, the alias slots in Google Workspace or Microsoft 365 are the right tool, and the documented limits are generous enough for normal use.

If you want a separate address for every registration and you care whether those addresses survive validation, skip the free disposable services and go to a provider that gives you aliases on a domain you own. The email forwarding domain you configure there is portable, and the aliases are real addresses rather than shared throwaways. That is the category worth paying for, and the price difference between providers in it is small compared to the cost of losing password resets.

One more check before you commit: test the alias against the forms you actually use. Sign up for two or three services you care about, watch whether the confirmation email arrives, and see whether the address survives in the account settings afterward. A service that passes that test on your own domain is worth more than one that is a dollar cheaper and fails on the fourth signup. Price is the easiest number to compare and the least useful one.